2004, Vol. 1, No. 1
Streams in the Desert:
Sources on the Spirit for Pentecostal Preachers
C. Aker, Ph.D.
New Testament and Exegesis at Assemblies of God Theological
Version (PDF, Download
Several decades ago, a great drought lay upon the land. Thirsty people looked every place for water, but it could not be found. Today, however, water is flowing and readily available as books, articles, and journals pay more attention to the Holy Spirit and related subjects. The level of Evangelical scholarship has moved up, and the effect of the charismatic renewal more than lingers. Pentecostal and charismatic scholars have ascended into the rain clouds of the academy to release much-needed water to the earth below.
For the Pentecostal preacher, abundant secondary sources
exist. Through these sources, persistent and concerned
students can access references to primary material
about the Spirit. These sources also feature prominent
hermeneutical methods that demonstrate how scholars deal
with the biblical text in its ancient environment. Consequently
preachers can observe and learn techniques not used by
evangelicals, let alone Pentecostals, some three or four
decades ago. They can become aware of what others are
thinking, writing, and
discussing in colleges, universities, and seminaries.
To a great degree, this shows the growth and sophistication
of charismatic and Pentecostal traditions. Many of
the authors whose work is referred to in this review
belong to these traditions and stand tall among biblical
In 1970, with the advent of the Society for
Pentecostal Studies (an association of scholars primarily
in the classical Pentecostal tradition), the controversy
over a few issues intensified. This is normal when scholars
address questions that arise from exegesis. For instance,
Gordon Fee raised the debate over the classical Pentecostal
doctrine of initial evidence. Are tongues normative in
Spirit baptism? Because the main argument by Pentecostals
focused on the Book of Acts, the debate centered on genre
and hermeneutics. Does history (i.e., the Book of Acts)
teach theology or simply record it as a historical fact?
In other words, is Acts prescriptive (i.e., containing
an “oughtness”)? Or is it merely
descriptive (i.e., recording facts that normally happen)?1 As
a teenager, Fee noted the hollow experiences speakers
seemed to generate in church and camp gatherings. They
emphasized speaking in tongues so much that many of Fee’s
peers, in his thinking, just manifested something like
gibberish. Wanting the experience to be genuine, Fee
sought to correct this kind of occurrence. Another issue
was latent within this one: Was Spirit baptism part of
the conversion process or separate from it?
In 1970, Frederick Dale Brunner published
a book on the Holy Spirit that was geared particularly toward
refuting the Pentecostal distinctive.2 It
became popular among Evangelicals because it was, at
the time, an exegetical response that seemed to destroy
the Pentecostal argument. I ran into it while in graduate
school where it had gained some status. In the preface,
Brunner admits his “dilemma.” He
was a systematician torn by his missionary vocation and forced
to do exegesis. Consequently, Brunner’s exegetical
foundations were extremely weak.
About the same time the
Society for Pentecostal Studies began,Dunn came out with
his Baptism in the Holy
Spirit: A Re-examination of the New Testament Teaching
on the Gift of the Spirit in Relation to Pentecostalism
much consternation among Pentecostals. 3 Later,
he followed up on some implications of experience that
arose in this book.4 James
D.G. Dunn advocated that the baptism in the Spirit is
the event in which the sinner becomes a believer and
receives the Spirit. He brought into vogue the term “conversion/initiation.” At
the same time, Dunn believed the Christian ought to have
more power with which to witness. A few years later,
Howard M. Ervin, who taught at Oral Roberts University,
responded to Dunn in Conversion-initiation
and the Baptism in the Holy Spirit: A Critique of James
D.G. Dunn, Baptism in the Holy Spirit.5Ervin
argued for the classical Pentecostal position that the
baptism of the Spirit was an experience distinct from
salvation and necessary for witness and other charismatic
activity. This brought into clear relief that the difference
among various theologies was over the order of the Spirit’s
experience in salvation. Dunn, and others, argued for
full reception at conversion. Pentecostals argued for
the baptism in the Spirit subsequent to and separate
from salvation. Still others (holiness traditions) identify
the order in three “works”:
conversion, sanctification, and Spirit baptism.
The Emergence of Journals
On the pastoral level, the journal Paraclete emerged in 1967 to provide a forum for Pentecostal, especially Assemblies of God, discussion.6Paraclete went out of existence, and its mission was continued partially in Enrichment magazine. Pneuma, the voice of the Society for Pentecostal Studies, though handling mostly historical articles, also provided a broader input on Pentecostal issues.7 In October 1992, Journal for Pentecostal Theology emerged to provide a more scholarly exegetical and theological forum for charismatics and Pentecostals. Sheffield
Academic Press of Sheffield, England, which publishes
this journal, also publishes its Journal of Pentecostal Theology Supplement Series.
The first in this series was Steve Land’s Pentecostal Spirituality: A Passion for the Kingdom, edited
by John Christopher Thomas, Rick D. Moore, and Steven
J. Land (1993). All these supplements are of interest,
but John Ruthven’s On the Cessation of the Charismata: The Protestant Polemic on Postbiblical Miracles #3 (1993) is worthy of special note.
One can search the Internet for particular journals but usually they do not offer the full text. A good beginning point is the pastorally oriented journal, Interpretation (www.interpretation.org). Indices for Pentecostal and Charismatic journals, including the Pneuma, the Journal of the European Pentecostal Theological Association, the Journal for Pentecostal Theology, and back issues of Paraclete can be accessed at:http://www.sps-usa.org/indices/pneuma.html. A free, but limited site for searching for articles on Pentecostal and charismatic issues is http://www.findarticles.com. Some journals, such as the Biblical Theology Bulletin, allow the user to copy the entire article, while others do not. For a more thoroughgoing search vehicle, EBSCOhost is available for a yearly subscription fee.8 It offers a bountiful supply of articles on an array of subjects in a variety of journals or periodicals by title, author, or subject. Articles from such journals provide rich material for developing sermons, Bible studies, and topical theological studies.
While I was teaching in a Bible college during the 1970s, a bright student passed through my hermeneutics class. Stephen Hendrickson, a music major, took hermeneutics because of his broad and focused interest in biblical studies. To pay his college costs, he began Christian Book Distributors out of the family garage in Lynn, Massachusetts, where his father pastored the local Assembly of God. By the time Stephen graduated from college, CBD was well on its way. From that early hermeneutics class, he saw the need and caught the vision to help alleviate the drought of Pentecostal materials. Together, we started Hendrickson Publishers in Peabody, Massachusetts.
One of the first proposals to come in was from Roger Stronstad.9 Following a recommendation by Bill Menzies, Roger Stronstad submitted his M.A. thesis from Regent College in Canada. We asked him to revise it for publication, and his book has blessed thousands of searching Pentecostals ever since. Stronstad, in contrast to Fee, argued that Acts as historical narrative is prescriptive (i.e., normative). Fee and Stronstad carried on the debate for some time in various articles and books.10
The present status of hermeneutics and the evolution
of the debate make this issue a historical one. Other
hermeneutical methods are being used, and new questions
are being asked. Dunn abandoned the discussion long ago,
coming out with only one recent article. Gordon Fee has
moved on as well.
From the start, Hendrickson Publishers’ goal was to give Pentecostal and charismatic writers a quality voice. Here are some of the titles that demonstrate the accomplishment of this goal. In the area of spiritual gifts are Ronald A.N. Kydd’s Charismatic Gifts in the Early Church: An Exploration Into the Gifts of the Spirit During the First Three Centuries of the Christian Church (1984);
and Siegfried Schatzmann’s A Pauline Theology of Charismata (1987).11 Stanley M. Burgess authored three volumes on the Spirit in the history of the Church: The Spirit and the Church: Antiquity (1984); The Holy Spirit: Eastern Christian Traditions (1989); and The Holy Spirit: Medieval Roman Catholic and Reformation Traditions (1997).12 Two Festschriften on Spirit issues, honoring two esteemed Pentecostal/Charismatic scholars, were published: Paul Elbert, ed., Faces of Renewal: Studies in Honor of Stanley M. Horton (1988) and Paul Elbert, ed., Essays on Apostolic Themes: Studies in Honor of Howard M. Ervin (1985). Howard Ervin produced another title: Spirit Baptism: A Biblical Investigation (1987), which is still valuable. Ronald A. N. Kydd wrote Healing Through the Centuries: Models for Understanding (1998).13
Other publishers saw the potential and began to produce books of interest to Pentecostals and charismatics. For example, Zondervan published Life in the Spirit: New Testament Commentary14and the New International Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements.15 Baker Book House published the 3 Crucial Questions Series. Two of them, geared toward a lay/pastoral level audience, are outstanding: Craig S. Keener, 3 Crucial Questions about the Holy Spirit and
Clinton Arnold’s 3 Crucial Questions about Spiritual Warfare.16
Books of Special Importance—Signs and Wonders
This section includes books to assist pastors and others
who look for biblical, theological guidance in the area
of signs and wonders, including how to deal with evil
powers. Most of these are monographs. Susan R. Garrett, The
Demise of the Devil: Magic and the Demonic in Luke’s
Writings gives detailed answers about the work of
Satan and shows how Jesus conquered him.17 In “The
Devil, Disease, and Deliverance: Origins of Illness in
the New Testament Thought,” Journal of Pentecostal
Theology Supplement Series 13 (Sheffield:
Sheffield Academic Press, 1998), John Christopher Thomas
provides a biblical overview of Satan’s work with
special reference to sickness and healing. This is must
reading for all Pentecostals. One should also consult
work on pagan religion and magic in Asia Minor: Ephesians:
Power and Magic: The Concept of Power in Ephesians in
Light of Its Historical Setting (first published
by Cambridge in 1989; Grand Rapids: Baker Book House
Company, paperback edition 1992, 1997); The Colossian
Syncretism: The Interface Between Christianity and Folk
Belief at Colossae (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books,
1996); and Powers of Darkness: Principalities and
Powers in Paul’s Letters (Downers Grove, IL:
InterVarsity Press, 1992). From an Assemblies of God
perspective and written in a non-technical style, see
Gary B. McGee and Benny C. Aker, Signs and Wonders
in Ministry Today (Springfield,
Mo.: Gospel Publishing House, 1996). For a response to
the cessationist’s position and defense of the
gifts of the Spirit from a non-Assemblies of God view
see The Kingdom and the Power.18 Important
also for this area is Graham H. Twelftree’s, Jesus
the Exorcist: A Contribution to the Study of the Historical
Jesus (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers (reprint
of J.C.B. Mohr), 1993).
Books of Importance—The Spirit
In the late 1980s and early 1990s, three authors working
on Ph.D.s and publishing in England elevated biblical-theological
studies on the Spirit in Luke-Acts to a higher level.
Robert Menzies, Max Turner, and Jim Shelton19 agreed
that Luke stresses the Spirit’s empowerment for
prophetic witness in Luke-Acts but they disagreed at
one point. Menzies, along with Stronstad, argued for
the doctrine of initial evidence via Luke’s view
of Spirit baptism. Though agreeing with Menzies about
the preponderance of inspired speech in Luke-Acts, Turner
carried on in Dunn’s
tradition but differed from him in some respects. Turner
believes that in Luke-Acts the Spirit is also involved
in conversion-initiation. Shelton appropriately noted
that Luke does not intend Spirit baptism to speak about
conversion-initiatio, but neither does he believe Luke
intends that the believer always should speak in tongues
when first filled with the Spirit as in the initial evidence
doctrine of the Classical Pentecostal.
All three authors employ redaction/composition criticism
to point out Luke’s theological interests, a
point Stronstad had made in different ways. The weakness
of Dunn, Turner, and Menzies is methodological, in
that they focus more on traditions behind the biblical
text to understand the biblical text than on the text
itself. Dunn does not do as well as Menzies or Turner
in searching out Jewish texts on the Spirit, leaning
toward form critical analysis that tends toward fragmenting
the text. Dunn, Menzies, Turner, and Shelton all fall
short by failing to employ narrative and social science
techniques. Stronstad has always urged interpreters
of Luke-Acts to recognize and embrace the narrative
genre of Luke-Acts and believes that narrative teaches
theology. Shelton does pay closer attention to the
text of Luke-Acts than does either Menzies or Turner.
The debate between Menzies and Turner (who are good friends) focuses on whether the Spirit is seen as doing anything other than inspiring believers to prophesy. Both argue from Jewish precedents but reach different conclusions. Menzies believes Luke teaches that the exclusive role of the Spirit in Luke-Acts is inspiration/prophecy. Turner believes that, in addition to causing people to prophesy, the Spirit does other things in Luke-Acts.
Another scholar, Blaine Charette, worked in the Gospel
of Matthew under the well-known English scholar, Graham
Stanton. He was encouraged to write a theology of the
Spirit, and it was published in the late 1990s. The value
of Charette’s little monograph is his methodology. He focuses firmly on the text of Matthew’s
Craig Keener’s The Spirit in the Gospels
and Acts: Divine Purity and Power (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson
Publishers, Inc., 1997) finished Hendrickson’s plan
to cover “The Spirit in the Bible” series
with Fee (Pauline) and Wilf Hildebrandt (OT).21 Keener’s
work, expanded from his dissertation, focused on two
issues he found current in Jewish literature as well
as in the New Testament: purity and power (especially
as manifested in prophecy).Though limited in the
number of biblical texts engaged, this work provides
a plethora of ancient texts—both Jewish and Greco-Roman—to help the
reader understand the historical, literary, and social
background of the Spirit in the Gospels and Acts. It was
written later than most of the works of Stronstad, Menzies,
Shelton, and Turner. Though some of their later discussion
happened after Keener’s work came out, they did
not engage it. Consequently, these volumes should be
Other valuable books are available in this area of interest
also (mentioned above briefly). The standard for years
to come is Gordon D. Fee’s God’s Empowering Presence: The Holy Spirit in the Letters of Paul (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1994).22 This book provides an excellent model for doing biblical theology. Part one, in which Fee exegetes the text, comprises the largest section. Part two, the synthesis, gathers the data into a biblical theology. Fee handles biblical-theological issues well and one does well to emulate his methodology. Arising from this work is his highly significant Paul, the Spirit, and the People of God (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1996). In it, Fee again visits the issues and summarizes them succinctly for a general reader.
Of value also are Craig S. Keener’s Gift and Giver: The Holy Spirit for Today (Grand
Rapids: Baker Academic, 2001) and Anthony D. Palma’s The Holy Spirit: A Pentecostal Perspective (Springfield,
MO: Logion Press, 2001). Ben Witherington III’s Jesus the Seer: The Progress of Prophecy (Peabody,
MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1999) traces prophecy
through the Bible and connects it with Jesus. This book
contains many insights for the Pentecostal. Though technical,
Max Turner’s The Holy Spirit and Spiritual Gifts (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1996) is a must for those who are interested in exploring spiritual gifts from a biblical perspective.
I have only scratched the surface here. Many more sources await the thirsty traveler. These references and lists are only representative and point toward a much fuller pool of water. They lead down the path to where streams flow. Most of these sources should not be read straight through, but used as commentaries. When working on a verse or topic, one should go to the contents page/index, list the page numbers that contain pertinent information, and go directly to those pages.
By drinking water from the Bible, as helped by these wonderful sources, pastors can raise their ministry to a new level with an added spiritual influence. Welcome to the journey.
D. Fee & Douglas Stuart, How to Read the Bible
for All It’s
Worth (Zondervan Publishing House, 1982). See also, “Baptism in the
Holy Spirit: The Issue of Separability and Subsequence,” Pneuma: The
Journal of the Society for Pentecostal Studies 7:2 (Fall, 1985): 87-99. How
to Read is in the third edition (November 2003). The latest removed and rewrote
Chapter six (“Acts—the Problem of Historical Precedent”) and
is now quite different. It is still useful with a helpful section on Bible translation.
2. Frederick Dale Bruner, A
Theology of the Holy Spirit: The Pentecostal Experience
and the New Testament Witness (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans
Publishing Company, 1970). This is typical of the Reformed
3. James D. G. Dunn, Baptism
in the Holy Spirit: A Re-examination of the New Testament Teaching
on the Gift of the Spirit in Relation to Pentecostalism Today (London:
S.C.M. Press Ltd., 1970).
and the Spirit: A Study of the Religious and Charismatic Experience
of Jesus and the First Christians as Reflected in the New Testament (Grand
Rapids, MI: Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1998; originally
London: SCM Press Ltd., 1975).
and the Baptism in the Holy Spirit: A Critique of James
D.G. Dunn, Baptism in the Holy Spirit (Peabody, MA:
Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1984).
6. Paraclete was
published between 1967 and 1995.
7. “The Society for Pentecostal
Studies, founded in 1970, was first envisioned by three men-William Menzies
of the Assemblies of God, Vinson Synan of the Pentecostal Holiness Church,
and Horace Ward of the Church of God. Formed with the intent "to“to
serve the church world by providing an authoritative interpretation of the
the Society directed its energies toward bringing scholarship on the
Pentecostal tradition to the fore.”http://www.sps-usa.org/about/history.html (Accessed
8. In a search engine, input these letters
and they will lead to a page with that website information. Just click on the
letters then and that will take you to the website for further information.
9. The Charismatic Theology of St.
Luke (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1984). Howard Ervin’s
book just mentioned was among them.
10. Much of
the debate carried on in private conversations but the
following illustrate these authors’ ongoing concerns.
Roger Stronstad, Spirit, Scripture and Theology: A Pentecostal Perspective (Baguio
City, Philippines: Asia Pacific Theological Seminary Press, 1995); Gordon D.
Fee, Gospel and Spirit: Issues in New Testament Hermeneutics (Peabody,
MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc. 1991).
11. Interestingly, one of the better
reviews of this out-of-print book is by Louis Richard Batzler in The Journal
of Religion and Psychical Research 14:4
(October 1991) 230-31. It can be accessed at http://web4.epnet.com.
12. These have been retitled and are
now out of print.
13. More titles will be mentioned
in a later section of this article.
14. Formerly Full Life Bible Commentary
to the New Testament, edited by French L. Arrington and Roger Stronstad
(Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1999).
15. Revised and expanded edition,
edited by Stanley M. Burgess and Eduard M. van der Maas (Grand Rapids: Zondervan,
16. (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1996
MN: Fortress Press, 1989); see also her “Exodus
from Bondage: Luke 9:31 and Acts 12:1-24,” Catholic Biblical Quarterly 52:4 (October,
18. Gary S. Greig and Kevin N. Springer,
eds. The Kingdom and the Power (Ventura,
CA: Regal Books, 1993). This contains articles from exegetical, theological,
historical, practical, and apologetical perspectives. Some articles
are stronger than others.
19. Robert Menzies, Empowered
for Witness: The Spirit in Luke-Acts,
revised (Sheffield, England: Sheffield Academic Press, 1994); Max
from on High: The Spirit in Israel’s Restoration and
Witness in Luke-Acts (Sheffield, England: Sheffield Academic
Press, 1996): and Jim Shelton, Mighty in Word and Deed: The Role
of the Holy Spirit in Luke-Acts (Peabody,
MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc. 1991).
20. In his
introduction to Restoring Presence: The Spirit in
Matthew’s Gospel (Sheffield, England: Sheffield
Academic Press, 2000), Charette notes this fact.
21. The following
data shows how much Keener has drawn from other primary
texts: of 282 pages, 218 pages are devoted to the body;
25 pages to “Select Bibliography of Sources Cited”;
9 pages to “Index of Modern Authors”; and 28 pages to “Index
of Ancient Sources.” Each chapter has copious endnotes usually numbering
in the hundreds. Wilf Hildebrandt, An Old Testament Theology of the
Spirit of God (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 1995).
22. See a review
article and Fee’s
response: Eduard Schweizer, “A Very Helpful Challenge: Gordon Fee’s Empowering
Presence,” Journal of Pentecostal Theology 8 (April 1996):7-21
and Gordon D. Fee, “God’s Empowering Presence: A Response
to Eduard Schweizer,” Journal of Pentecostal Theology 8 (April
Monday, February 6, 2006 12:29 PM